Grafische Darstellung von Reduktion im Wein AI Generiert

Reduction is a term from chemistry that describes the process of an atom or molecule gaining electrons.

An atom that gains electrons is reduced. Since the electrons must come from somewhere, a reaction partner is needed to release the electrons. The release of electrons is called oxidation. The molecule that gains electrons is thus reduced and thereby oxidizes its reaction partner, and vice versa. The entire process is called a redox reaction, and redox chemistry is a vast field of chemistry. So much for the deterrent; for those who have persevered this far, we now turn to wine.

When speaking of reductive notes in wine or a reductive wine, one refers to specific aromas caused by sulfur compounds. Sulfur is one of the few non-metals that, firstly, can occur in many different oxidation states, and secondly, is found in numerous organic compounds that, thirdly, often have a very intense smell. These three properties together explain why sulfur compounds are so crucial for the organoleptic impression of reductive wines. And with that, I come to the aroma profile and the smell of reductive wines.

Domaine Coche-Dury in the bottle

Domaine Coche-Dury is considered the quasi-inventor of reductive wines.

 

Olfactorily, two fundamentally different types of reduction in wine can be distinguished. I call them mineral and organic reduction due to their olfactory associations. More pedantically, one could also speak of sulfidic and sulfurous reduction. Since we Germans have difficulties with the intonational distinction between hard and soft consonants (be careful when you order crabcake!), I prefer to speak of mineral and mercaptan reduction.

Mineral reduction has a mineral odor, sometimes reminiscent of sulfur dioxide, and can be caused by sulfites, among other things. In ascending concentration, these odors are:

– siliceous mineral (wet gravel or pebbles)

– flinty (the smell produced when striking sparks with flint and pyrite, which is also chemically identical to the smell of a handgun barrel or rifle some time after firing)

– smell of spent primers or black powder.

These odors are not only due to sulfur(IV) compounds such as sulfur dioxide (anhydride of sulfurous acid) and organic sulfur compounds of the same oxidation state, but also to specific thiols such as benzyl mercaptan or 2-furylmethanethiol, which have an empyreumatic, smoky odor. Traces of disulfane and trisulfane, which smell of camphor in higher concentrations, can also be responsible for a siliceous-mineral to flinty odor.

Organic or mercaptan reduction is caused by sulfides. The most prominent is hydrogen sulfide, whose anion is the sulfide ion. Hydrogen sulfide smells of rotten eggs even in the lowest concentrations. Hydrogen sulfide is, by the way, even more toxic than hydrocyanic acid, but since it smells several orders of magnitude stronger than hydrocyanic acid, poisoning with hydrogen sulfide almost never occurs. Organic sulfides, called mercaptans or thiols, as well as thioethers, play a larger role in wine. They too are intensely odorous even in low concentrations. A wine fault caused by hydrogen sulfide and mercaptans is called ‘Böckser’. Mercaptans and thioethers smell of rotten vegetables, and in low concentrations, of cooked cabbage and asparagus water. Another aroma of reductive wines is the smell of hot rubber, caused by organic disulfides. The terms “mineral” and “organic” reduction are thus derived from the aroma profile.

Both groups of sulfur compounds have a reducing effect, which is why such wines are referred to as reductive. While mineral reduction is currently in vogue and highly valued by many wine drinkers, organic reduction is critical and, if too pronounced, constitutes a wine fault. To complicate matters, certain mercaptans are also responsible for desirable aromas, such as 3-mercaptohexan-1-ol, 3-mercaptohexyl acetate, 4-mercapto-4-methylpentan-2-one, and 4-mercapto-4-methylpentan-2-ol, which smell of citrus fruits, grapefruit, and passion fruit. So much for the taste of reductive wines. Now, a bit of (bio)chemistry is in order to get to the bottom of the causes of reduction in wine.

How do these reductive notes get into the wine?

The layman might think of the sulfuring of wines. However, the desired mineral reduction notes are not achieved through the usual sulfuring of the wine. In fact, yeasts are responsible for these sulfur compounds. The sulfur sources are, on the one hand, sulfate, which the yeasts reduce via sulfite to sulfide to produce the amino acids cysteine and methionine. Towards the end of fermentation, cell growth ceases, and the yeast no longer needs amino acids. The enzyme sulfite reductase, which is responsible for the reduction of sulfite to sulfide, is no longer supplied by the yeast but continues to produce sulfite, which is then excreted from the yeast cell. In this way, yeasts can increase the SO2 content of the wine to up to 30 mg/l without the winemaker having to sulfur.

Graphical representation of the chemical formula for reduction in wine

However, the main cause of excessive hydrogen sulfide excretion by yeasts is nitrogen deficiency. Nitrogen is an essential building block of all amino acids. If yeasts do not have enough assimilable nitrogen available, they cannot utilize the sulfide obtained from sulfate and excrete it as hydrogen sulfide. If necessary, they can also obtain nitrogen by breaking down the sulfur-containing amino acid cysteine. This produces hydrogen sulfide as a waste product, which is also excreted from the yeast cell. As a strong nucleophile, the sulfur in hydrogen sulfide is very reactive and, in subsequent reactions, forms mercaptans such as methane and ethanethiol, as well as thioethers such as dimethyl sulfide, which can contribute to the complexity of a wine in the lowest concentrations, but can also cause unpleasant aromas of cooked or even decaying vegetables in relatively low concentrations.

The situation is complicated by sulfur-containing compounds that can enter the must not only through plant protection products but also be synthesized by the sulfur metabolism of yeasts. These compounds can also generate reductive aromas in already bottled wine via complex reaction cascades, which are schematically shown in the figure below.

Reductive wines are vinified under reductive conditions, i.e., in the absence of oxygen. Sulfuring with the reducing agent sulfur dioxide also contributes to reductive conditions. Interestingly, however, long-lived, mineral-reductive white wines that are not very susceptible to oxidation can also be produced with must oxidation. Flavonoid phenols play an important role in the oxidative aging of white wines and the formation of aging notes. Through must oxidation before fermentation, these flavonoids are already oxidized in the must and can thus be removed. In this process, the grape’s own polyphenol oxidases enzymatically oxidize these phenols, which then become insoluble and precipitate from the must. Fermentation and subsequent aging of the wine can then take place under reducing conditions, where the oxidative aroma compounds formed in the must are also completely reduced again, so that a reductive wine is produced despite must oxidation.

If you have read this far and still haven’t quite understood it because you never paid attention in chemistry, we at Weinbanausen.ch offer an explanation for the layman.

Leave A Comment


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.