
Merchants are not happy with this year’s Bordeaux En Primeur campaign. The question now is: are the châteaux slaughtering the goose that lays the golden eggs?
Looking at this campaign (and the one before, and the one before that, and the one before that…), I’m reminded of a saying of my grandmother’s: “If you’re in a hole, stop digging.” Apparently, that saying isn’t really known in Bordeaux.
Because the château owners in Bordeaux stubbornly refuse to believe that they’re in a hole—and from their point of view, they’re not in one either. The producers have sold their 2022s, or at least the portion they’ve released, and so now it’s someone else’s problem. And yes, it was a fantastic year with fantastic wines. Those who bought some can comfortably pat themselves on the back, because they’ll have excellent wines sitting in their wine storage.
The problem, as seen by the part of the trade that doesn’t own a château, is that not enough people took part. Matthew O’Connell of Bordeaux Index considers 2022 a small, insignificant campaign. Otherwise, no one wants to speak officially. But the general sentiment is the same everywhere: “Far too expensive,” “the whole idea of en primeur wines is digging its own grave,” all the way to “en primeur is dead.” At which point I have to quietly stifle a cough, remembering that I said much the same thing myself years ago. But as the saying goes, those pronounced dead always seem to live a little longer.

The gap between Bordeaux and the rest of the world only seems to keep widening. The wines are very good—no one disputes that. Nor does anyone dispute that, in a hot, dry year that could have produced entirely different aromas, they triumphed and yielded great wines. But as always, the Bordelais once again believe they’ve made the greatest wine in history. In truth, they probably had more luck than judgment, since it’s almost a minor miracle that the wines didn’t turn out as sweet and lush as in 2003, but rather in more of a “classic style.” That doesn’t make the vintage, or its wines, the best of all time.
Then there’s the matter of price, which rose by an average of 15 percent. For the top-notch châteaux, it was even 20 to 40 percent, which amounts to a hefty surcharge. Naturally, the collectors who buy every year are buying this year too—just less.
It’s simply in the nature of things: the trade wants to sell wine. Yes, one could argue that for as long as anyone can remember, some merchants have warned of price increases every single year, and then gone ahead and bought the wines and sold them to their clients anyway. How does that saying go again? “Preach water and drink wine”—or was it the other way around? But I suspect the trade’s real strength is simply its ability to bleat the same old refrain in unison. Yet when a major merchant points out that “only two out of the last 10 en primeur campaigns have actually worked properly,” perhaps we should remind ourselves what en primeur is actually meant to be for.
Happy Châteaux
So how did things used to work? For the châteaux, en primeur was originally a means of generating cash flow. Today, the producers for whom en primeur still works well—generally only the big names—no longer need that cash flow so urgently, if at all.
For consumers, however, quite a lot has changed. In the past, you could assume that if you laid down a few cases in your wine storage, the price on the secondary market would steadily rise over the following 15 to 20 years. With a few exceptions, that model is now dead.
But even if you accept that this model is no longer in step with the times, you have to ask why you’d want to pay more en primeur for a wine you can’t even drink yet than for an already-matured vintage of the same wine. The châteaux’s answer is as simple as a door-to-door vacuum salesman’s pitch: they claim to simply make better wine today than they used to. It was always good, but now it’s supposedly even better. Et voilà, a 20% increase is justified.
At Angelus, you’d have to go back to 2009 to find a vintage that currently costs more than the 2022 en primeur. The 2022 costs around CHF 5,180 for a case of 12 in Switzerland; the 2019 is available for CHF 4,390, the 2010 for CHF 4,900, and the 2009 for CHF 5,600. After that, prices drop again, before the 2005 becomes somewhat more expensive once more.
There are more examples of this than one would like: Ducru-Beaucaillou or Léoville-Las Cases, for instance. Here, the ’22 costs more than the 2016, which has repeatedly been rated 100 points.
If you ask people to pay more for a 2022 than for a vintage that’s already known to be great and is already ready to drink, you’re missing the whole point of en primeur. The idea behind en primeur is to buy an unready wine at a much lower price than a mature one, store it for 15 years, and then sell it or drink it. If you break these rules, the whole concept simply stops making sense.
The 2019 was released during Covid, and many people bought en primeur again, but the Bordelais at the time apparently felt cheated. As you’ll recall, prices were significantly lower back then. On one hand, the market was briefly disrupted; on the other, the US imposed 15% punitive tariffs on wines from the EU. And as things look now, the producers want to make a real comeback. The trouble is that buyers assumed 2019 prices were back where they should be. That illusion didn’t last long.
So the trade was absolutely determined to make this year’s campaign a success. After all, a good en primeur campaign isn’t just six or seven weeks of the trade’s undivided attention on Bordeaux—and thus the kind of publicity for the region that money simply can’t buy—it also fuels interest in Bordeaux for the rest of the year. Ideally, just as that interest begins to wane, another successful campaign comes along to give things the necessary push again. The 2019 campaign worked beautifully this way: interest was high, and consumers seemed happy with the pricing. But this year, “we’re not seeing any increased interest in the older vintages,” according to one merchant. “This campaign hasn’t helped boost interest in Bordeaux—and that fact tends to get conveniently overlooked.”

Bordeaux primeur tasting. Image: Adrian van Velsen
The Négociant Blues
But from conversations with château owners, one increasingly gets the impression that some of them resent the profits made by négociants—and perhaps, by extension, retailers too. The general sentiment often seems to be: sometimes you make money, sometimes you don’t—c’est la vie? That’s a shame, and in my opinion it calls into question a system that has worked well for so long. Will it keep going like this much longer? I have my doubts.
Of course, not all négociants are alike: some are huge and can afford to hold stock and sell it over the long term. Others are smaller and can’t afford to hold much in storage. These smaller players do well in years when they can resell everything immediately, or when interest rates sit at 0.8%, as they did last year. Now, at 4 to 4.5 percent, financing their purchases over two years works out to more than 9 percent. Most négociants are probably working with margins of 3 to 12 percent. A handful of top operators—perhaps the first five or ten—earn more, but for the rest, margins are very thin, and it’s not really a good business to be in.
It also appears that many négociants voluntarily reduced their allocations for certain wines this year. That’s a risky move, because if you don’t take up your full allocation from the major châteaux, you don’t get it back. Négociants have one month to decide once a château has released its offer. That’s a lot of pressure and very little time to make sound decisions.
Customer Service? A Nod to Barton
The Bartons know how to look after their customers. In my experience, châteaux run by modest people who also travel the world tend to understand their customers and don’t try to pull a fast one on them. Châteaux run by professionals on behalf of absent owners tend to care less about their customers. But before anyone in that second category starts reaching for their lawyer’s number, I should add that there are exceptions—in both categories.
This year, though, it wasn’t all bad news. Some wines were oversubscribed, with consumers unable to get enough of them; and if you’re still considering a purchase, there are some lesser-known wines available at reasonable prices, offering a good ratio between score and price.
Several sources point out that the small volume of wine released was actually a positive factor. It presumably means the wines actually sold. Of course, it was a small vintage to begin with, but beyond that, some châteaux released only half their wine. Had they released it the old way, in larger tranches, the wines likely wouldn’t have sold in 95 percent of cases.
But this new model of releasing so little wine also raises questions about the future of en primeur. It’s probably only the top châteaux holding back this much, or perhaps they’re testing just how far they can push the en primeur market and still get away with it. Are they trying to imitate Burgundy by bringing small volumes to market? Or are they simply pleased to have set new reference prices for en primeur wines and shifted enough volume to call it—from their point of view—a success?

